Ramadan. Did The Protestant Christian Sect Come Into Being After Reading Hadiths?

Ramadan : Did The Protestant Christian Sect Come Into Being After Reading Hadiths

The bible says you have to believe and do good deeds to get into heaven. The quran says the same. But protestants and hadith-followers say it doesnt matter what youve done- so long as you believe, youre guaranteed eternal heaven. This isnt in the holy books of either religions. So did protestants copy hadiths, or did it spontaenously arise in both religions? ~~~ FF ~~~

Best Answer To Ramadan Question

" hadith-followers say it doesnt matter what youve done- so long as you believe, youre guaranteed eternal heaven " Where in which book it says this ? lol , Aren`t you Tusonites believes any one who dies before the age 40 goes eternal Heaven ! whether he believes or not !

All Answer To Ramadan Questions

Answer 1

The Protestant deviated from the Roman Catholic church and decided to take out some books from the Bible . Tobit and Maccabees. Hadith followers choose to add books with the Quran to give them reassurance that they have a book to interpretate the Quran. Slave of Allah- I thought Muhammad said follow the Quran and Sunnah. When did he ever mention the Hadiths?

Answer 2

I dont know about Protestants, ask them. As for the Ahadith, I have, yet, not seen a single Hadith which assures you direct entrance into heaven by only "believing". Could you please cite some authentic ones?

Answer 3

That allegation about Muslims is not true. I follow both Quran and Hadiths and I am trying my level best to become a practicing Muslim. Read Sorah Asr.

Answer 4

Actually, the protestant church came into being because an English king wanted a divorce, and the pope wouldnt give him one. Although during the dark ages, most Europeans were illiterate, and probably would have remained so if not for the Muslims living in Europe at that time, I highly doubt that when they started reading, it was the hadiths the Christians picked up.

Answer 5

" hadith-followers say it doesnt matter what youve done- so long as you believe, youre guaranteed eternal heaven " Where in which book it says this ? lol , Aren`t you Tusonites believes any one who dies before the age 40 goes eternal Heaven ! whether he believes or not !

Answer 6

how about lying? where does it get you?

Answer 7

Sunnis believe that all Muslims in hell will eventually go to heaven , no matter what they did as long as they say " there is no God but Allah " , that is what the Jews were thinking also and it was recorded in the Quran and note what Allah said to them in the verse : The Jews said "Hell will not touch us, except for a limited number of ; Say, "Have you taken such a pledge from GOD - GOD never breaks His pledge - or, are you saying about GOD what you do not know?" 2:80

Answer 8

please shut up

Answer 9

they are not linked.. honestly i agree that one has to have a good heart...but with a good heart generally comes good deeds and the know how to sacrife for what you love and believe... words are easy.... actions and the internal goodness are linked... you cant not cure your spirit and then just coz you believe you go to heaven... if you really truely believe you do your best to be good to others to be sure you get eternal life.. dunno if i explained myself.... protestants and hadiths have nothing in common, maybe just a bit of too much human thinking

Answer 10

The Mutazilah are from the Rationalist school of thought and have very many deviations in their methodological principles These people are the Rejecters of the Sunnah, and spring from the works of Ghulaam Ahmad Parweiz and Rashad Khalifa, both of whom were declared apostates, due to their very clear and apparent kufr. In the time of the tabi`in, in the days of Hasan al-Basri in particular, Wasil ibn `Ata emerged with his concept of "the station between the two ; He claimed that a Muslim who commits a major sin is no longer a believer, nor is he a kafir, but that he is in an intermediate station between kufr and Eemaan - that of fisq (transgression) and will remain eternally in Hell. Imam Hasan expelled them from his circle (halaqah), and they isolated themselves near one of the pillars of the mosque. As a result, they became known as "Al-Mu`tazilah", meaning: the Isolated Ones. The Mu`tazilah eventually fragmented into twenty separate sects, each pronouncing kufr on the rest, and whose common ground was an over-emphasis on the use of the mind. They tried to interpret Islam in the light of first-order logic. Their other beliefs included: That it is permissible, lexically, to ascribe creation of deeds to human beings. That the Qurân is created. That the attributes of Allah are not eternal. Interpretation of allegorical verses without exception, so that they denied that the believers will see Allah in the Hereafter.

Answer 11

It is Islamic orthodoxy that all Muslims no matter how sinful will enter jannah even if they have to be punished for their sins first Whoever believes otherwise -that a Muslim can be in hell for eternity is a khariji heretic

Answer 12

"But protestants and hadith-followers say it doesnt matter what youve done- so long as you believe, youre guaranteed eternal ; Thats the belief of the Murjiyyah, not the people of Islaam. Stupidity is a sickness cured by knowledge. But when people who fake knowledge due to arrogance, they shy away from the real cure and continue to fool themselves thinking they are upon guidance. Such are the Quraanites, the liars and distorters of the Book of Allaah, the followers of vein desires and ill-intended interpretations.

Answer 13

When stupidity is prevailing , they force sunnis to believe in the superstitions and the lies attributed to the prophet in Bukhari and other hadith books . Some people here seem to be very ignorant about hadith books or maybe they know it but they are stupid enough to believe the many lies there !